By Human Rights Law Alliance (HRLA)
The legal battle in the landmark Tickle v Giggle case has reached the end of the road.
The High Court has refused female-only networking app Giggle for Girls and its owner Sall Grover special leave to appeal the Full Federal Court’s decision against them.
For Ms. Grover, that means the case is over. There is no further avenue of appeal.
The decision leaves in its wake a deeply concerning outcome for freedom of speech and association.
“Serious Implications For Australians”
Giggle was created as an online space for women.
But the courts found that excluding Roxanne Tickle, a transgender-identifying man, amounted to unlawful discrimination on the basis of gender identity under the Sex Discrimination Act (SDA) 1984.
The outcome has serious implications for Australians who believe that biological sex matters in law and for the freedom to form and maintain associations based on sex.
There is, however, an important legal qualification.
The High Court’s refusal of special leave does not mean it heard a full appeal and endorsed the Full Federal Court’s reasoning.
Confusion Between Biological Sex And Gender Remains
Interestingly, the High Court specifically addressed section 7D of the SDA which allows certain measures aimed at achieving substantive equality.
Legal academic Associate Professor Neil Foster from the University of Newcastle suggests the way the Court dealt with the application may leave open the possibility of a future case squarely addressing the meaning of “sex” under the Act.
For now the legal confusion between biological sex and gender remains.
The Sex Discrimination Act needs to provide a clear and truthful definition of sex and properly protect single-sex spaces and associations.
“Parliament Should Correct This”
Calls for legislative change have already been made by political figures including Angus Taylor, Tony Abbott and Pauline Hanson.
Whatever future litigation may bring, Australians should not have to spend years in court to discover whether the law permits them to recognise biological sex.
Parliament should correct the deficiencies in the law directly rather than leaving Australians to discover the boundaries of their freedoms through costly litigation.
“Discussion Of Defence Deeply Flawed”
Associate Professor Foster who runs the blog Law and Religion Australia wrote:
I am disappointed that the High Court of Australia has denied special leave to appeal the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court.
I have previously provided a detailed comment on the Full Court decision in which I argued that the Federal Court’s discussion of the defence was deeply flawed.
The decision wrongly interprets a provision that Parliament had said provided a defence against all discrimination actions where “special measures” had been put in place to achieve substantive equality between men and women.
The Full Court said a “distributive” reading was preferred, linking defences only to one specific ground of possible discrimination at a time.
But it acknowledged that this was not the most natural way to read the text.
“Refusals Of Special Leave Are Not a Binding Precedent”
The “special leave” system in the High Court of Australia is clearly needed to provide some management of the workload of a busy court which hears appeals from all over the country.
Refusals of special leave do not, however, amount to a binding precedent of any sort, as they have to be disposed of quickly.
That means that this decision does not stand for the proposition that the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court below was “correct”.
Even though the court said that there were not “sufficient prospects of success”, that does not mean the lower decision is formally approved.
Regret That Decision Will Be Influential
This means that the decision retains the status it already had — a decision of a superior appellate court which is formally binding on judges below in the Federal Court of Australia and lower federal courts.
Other State and Territory courts will treat the decision as persuasive, but may decide not to follow it, if there are good reasons not to do so.
Nevertheless, the Full Court decision will be influential in other similar cases, and this is to be regretted.
It entrenches the view that (unless defences from other parts of the SDA apply, such as sections 37 and 38 for religious groups) women-only spaces cannot generally be established where there are biological males who assert the right to be treated as female.
It seems that the quickest route to changing this situation will now require Parliament to amend the SDA to represent biological reality.
The post Expert Legal View On Landmark Sex And Gender Case appeared first on Vision Christian Media.
